Saturday 14 March 2009

What it really means to be Indian


There is a reason why I usually do not discuss weighty issues here,I have no solution to offer and I do not like to see myself drawing attention writing on issues I have only heard of or read about.But,that does not mean I do not have troubling questions lingering on in my head.My last journey back home was a time for heavy contemplation.Thankfully,I was among people whose actions did not bother me all that much and I was left undisturbed in the comfort of my reticence.If you travel by the Indian Railways,you might warm up to the actuality that you ,my friend,are a citizen of a country called India.That is,if you are not still in school,chorusing the national anthem daily or are a regular fan cheering for the Indian cricket team.As the train effortlessly crawls like a snake across the country lands,trudging on from one state to another in total disrespect for borders that really do not exist,it feels more like a drive through the sanctuary of humanity.The bustle of the slums,the clamour of small temples,the quiet of endless tracts of farmland,the smoke billowing out of the occasional chimney and me,the spectator, trying passionately to work up any remote,long-lost sense of bonding that I might have with the changing world outside my window. I rediscover,India and me,its an old story:
Being born into a family that is not even remotely military or political,my introduction to the ethos of nationalism was mostly through textbooks.I was told that a certain bald ,bespectacled man was the father of our nation and the fight for freedom of our country was something to be remembered with awe and pride.It was a little difficult ,I tell you ,to believe that the sleepy nonchalance of my colony had to be earned with sweat and blood.Nevertheless,the mere sight of the national flag made oodles of patriotism appear from nowhere and swim in my little heart as if they owned the place.The earliest memory I have of representing India in some small ,sweet way was when I narrated the story of the Taj Mahal to a Russian friend who was a neighbour with a show of sentiment so rare that he must have mistaken me for some distant relative of Shah Jahan himself.But the true weight of embodying a country full of conflicting shades was felt when a friendly Australian tourist teased me asking if all Indians were effeminate,dreamy poets like yours truly and other Bengalis he had met,I swallowed my discomfort and managed to reply with a chuckle that it was unfortunate that he had not met a Sardar yet. Thinking of the futility of trying to bundle together such an amazing myriad of cultures with the strands of a shared nationhood,I was led to wonder whether India really wasn't a continent forced to behave like a country ,if the Punjabis are not as different from the Bengalis as the Spanish are from the Germans.
Also,from the very beginning,I was always bewildered at the way nationhood was practised around me.How people making a living out of partisan politics were foremost in wearing their nationality on their sleeves,At one point I was close to concluding that National days like the Republic Day and the Independence Day were grand designs ,annual checks to ensure India never lost itself totally to infighting.Another curious case which baffled me was how this self-proclaimed secular state had all its military equipment named after Hindu mythological figures. Perhaps,a nation possessing the most contrasting of realities should be pardoned such eccentricities.
Often,I opened up the atlas and felt humbled at how Vizag,my adopted hometown,barely clung to the knees of the nation and judging by how far it was from Delhi,I surmised that anything that happened at the capital must surely die down to mere bits and pieces of news till it reached us.Thus,I barely felt the force of politics and national affairs in my life (Unlike my friends from the metros who would surely have missed school on days of some bloody curfew or the other)and I reaffirmed my belief that the stories in newspapers served no more than as fodder for adult gossip.With the rise of a sense of intellect,I too brandished my bookish knowledge of current affairs to earn brownie points in debates and discussions.By late adolescence,I had mastered the art of carping eloquent on corruption,poverty ,red-tapism,communalism and other such popular Indian problems.
In addition to this,a funnier thing was happening,through an array of shallow magazines,I was being fed on the magnificence of the great American dream and very soon,I set my eyes on becoming the poster boy NRI entrepreneur,a vision of myself that I have given up,only recently.A glimpse of what I see as the last resurgence of such timorously formed ideas can be had at my post here.Besides having a good laugh,I hope you will enjoy the innocence of my youthful brashness.I have been lucky all along to have lived off on the benefits of being Indian.Not everyone shares my fortune.Certainly,not the people killed in the recent terrorist attacks,they paid the price for being Indians with their lives.
When I was two, my parents decided to migrate to the South and make it their new home.After all,they were Indians and had secured in patrimony the right to reside in any part of a sprawling landmass.Studying and playing with my friends from AP,I grew to like their culture ,relish their cuisine and love their women,all this as Bengali reduced itself to a language used for verbal communication at home.At school,my favourite and most beloved teacher was Telugu,I don't think I could have exploited any more the bond of Indianness.Father's job at the Steel plant made sure life saw no dearth on the material side,the love of mother at home and of teacher's at school left me carefree enough to build the reputation of naughtiness that I am so very fond of and permitted me the extravagance of limiting my affiliation to my family and my school.Even today,I am not completely unmindful of the privileges of studying at the Indian Institute of Technology,luxuriating in the blind pursuit of knowledge,all on taxpayer's money.
The feeling I have for this country is not as much a case of patriotism as it is of solidarity and empathy that comes with twenty years of acquaintance with any place.India ,in my eyes, has grown from the country about which I once read in my textbooks,from the nation whose struggle for independence I parroted in exams to a larger-than-life entity which has embraced me and allowed me the arrogance to look down upon its weaknesses,the freedom to have grandiose dreams and the unfettered opportunities to chase them.
I am a young man,you see.I have only begun to ruminate and have opinions.I have to stand up to the endless barrage of new complexities and the only way I can do it is by taking and switching sides,a continuous revision of viewpoints.I do not wrap myself in the tricolour but I am surely not running away from the truth of the country where I was born.I have had my brief flirtations with anarchy and willingly played soundboard to a close friend's parochial anti-India rants but at the end of the day,it is more than a passing observation for me when I see how life has an uncanny way about coming back full circle because,in some ways,I realize,I have come to love this place alongwith its bamboozling contradictions,its amusing paradoxes.

Sunday 8 March 2009

The doomed search for "I"


"I" am Ravi."I" like writing."I" am a Bengali."I" am studying to be a Mechanical Engineer.

But who is this "I" and what does it point to?Is there some entity out there that possesses the "exclusive rights" over this particular permutation of attributes which make "me" me?Do all the I's point to the same thing and if so,why?If not,does I really mean anything?Is it not just like any other letter of the alphabet except that it bears the misfortune of being the ultimate source and cause of every activity,the syllable that spews all Ego.Many would disagree and it appears that they have been in this state of constant denial since the very invention of language.The writer of this post recently read that perhaps,the oldest word in the English language is I.Each one of us,human beings is an ego-maniac to some degree.We might not tell it aloud,but we love to take responsibility for our actions,good or evil,it makes us feel alive.Life is a huge playground,we may win or loose,play till the end or get injured in between but we do not like to sit on the bench and watch things rolling past us like a movieAnd amidst all these actions,stands "I" ,like a beacon ,reminding us of how lonely we are in the choices we make and how we are always caught in the web of circumstances,trapped like 'bugs in the amber",no one ever bothering to redeem us,simply because no one can.
Being fanatically individualist,he would have been really happy if things were really the way he has just described .How wonderful it is to think that "I" am truly the center of the universe,just like how the men of the Renaissance had postulated.How wonderful it is to know that everything you ever did carries in itself the mark of your free will .That brief period in self -aggrandizing bliss did not last long.Ravi was reading random articles on conjoined twins when he discovered this shocking picture of two babies conjoined in the head.What was this,a brutal anomaly or a revealing omen?Not that he hadn't seen it before ,but this time it had brought to him the most disturbing of epiphanies.These two actually shared a brain,the temple where "I" resides and thus shared "I."They could have shared anything else,they could have shared a heart,a limb,kidneys,stomach,anything! but they shared the brain,suddenly "I",the origin of one,pointed to two ,"I"seemed to loose it's hallowed standing,it was sheer treachery on its part.How stupid he felt to be living on a delusion for his twenty long years.He felt like burning his beloved novel of adolescence-the Fountainhead.John Galt looked a living mass of lie.He felt like reaching out to Galt's heart and extinguishing the soul out of it.It did not deserve to exist,A blatant betrayal suffered at the hands of what he glorified to be the most novel of virtues-individuality.That next day,he attended all classes,had all my meals,wrote every word that came out of every professor's mouth and slept on time.He even went a step ahead and contributed most willingly to the most banal of all conversations,and took great pleasure to be classed ,even if for an instance as "normal" and "sensible".A return to docility appeared to be the surest expression of a rebellion against the Ego.It was with its soothing revelations,though.When one child in the photo grimaced when the other was pained,it betrayed to him the wellspring of human values like charity and compassion.The inevitable fact that all human beings are connected to each other just like how these two were,now stared into his face.Paulo Coelho's concept of the Universal Soul no longer sounded so mushy to him.And taking the liberty to widen the scope of Jung's ideas,it seemed the only consciousness is the collective one.
He looked back at his small personal history with heavy distaste instead of pride.Peering harder at what he thought to be some of his greatest acts of self-assertion,he saw now how each one of them can be traced back to the most trivial of incidents.If he was allowed to go back and change just one moment of his past,he was pretty sure he would end up as quiet an antithesis of what he was now.It dawned on him what the Joker means when he calls himself the agent of chaos .Actually,we all are.Just that only the Joker is aware of it. But,do not worry ,He will not turn into Joker, he will keep writing many such crazy posts.He finds a lot of solace in making literature out of his own tragedy and he thinks it is exactly what Theodore Melnechuk is trying to do in these beautiful lines of poetry:

Our puppet strings are hard to see,

So we perceive ourselves as free,

Convinced that no mere objects could,

behave in terms of bad and good.

............................

We seem to from a nested set,

with each the last one's marionette,

who, if you ask him, would insist

that he is the last ventriloquist.

May Rene Des Cartes turn in his grave.He was wrong,because "I" think he was. :)